Thoughts from a scrambled brain... or, My solutions to all the worlds problems... or, ummm, what was the question?
Wednesday, 13 September 2017
Thursday, 24 August 2017
Popper's Paradox
Free speech,
Tolerance,
Unconditional love...
How do these things work in reality?

In 1945 the philosopher Karl Popper proposed the paradox of tolerance.
In a nutshell he said "if a society is tolerant without limit, their ability to be tolerant will eventually be seized or destroyed by the intolerant", or to paraphrase that: we can only survive by being intolerant about intolerance.
As we all know, white supremacy and all it's ugly variants are making headlines and empowering those who secretly embrace those views to speak out. There's also the current political mess in Australia over gay marriage, where conservative christians are doing all they can to stop it.
So where do we draw the line on free speech and religious freedom?
We have to draw it somewhere, or our society will become victim to it and we will loose those very freedoms!
The balance is in how we confront them. If we use "violence" (physical, vocal or in any form) we are playing the same game, and when confronted in this way, the intolerant simply dig their heels in and use the opposition to fuel more intolerance.
Respect for their humanity is key. To recognise that we could be the same if we'd been raised in a different environment is a sobering thought. It's a learned trait, something we aren't just born with. So compassion and empathy is the key to any communication, bypassing the rhetoric and reactionary thought processes and focussing on understanding why people are like this.
At the risk of being overly simplistic, it comes down to a lack of love. They never experienced the type of unconditional love themselves that breeds self worth and empathy for others. They are broken and angry, but instead of looking within, they are lashing out at the rest of us.
But they still have to be stopped from spreading this disease, and that's where we have to draw lines. Although love is the only "cure" for these people, we still have to deal with the affects they are having on our society.
The alt right issue is pretty obvious, but the christian right style of bigotry, especially towards LGBT people is more complex because of the religious freedom problems. And that opens a very large can of worms because it will eventually confront all religions on issues of bigotry and tolerance.
Perhaps it's time we stop being afraid of challenging people's belief systems?
We can do this with love and patience without compromising our stand. They believe they are doing the right thing, so we have to talk to their hearts, bypass the religious rhetoric and present compassion and empathy for the broken as our motivation.
We also have to remember that for most christians it's a case of "the bible says so", and that's a tough nut to crack. But with the same level of compassion we can help them to understand that their views are in error, as have been so many christian opinions over the centuries, that had to be adjusted and morality, ethics and science outgrew the ignorance of ancient culture.
We must be strong but loving - compassionate but without compromise - draw the lines but help them gently step over them. It's hard work, but if we can step back from our own reactionary thought processes we will be able to exercise the love they need to see in action.
Tolerance,
Unconditional love...
How do these things work in reality?

In 1945 the philosopher Karl Popper proposed the paradox of tolerance.
In a nutshell he said "if a society is tolerant without limit, their ability to be tolerant will eventually be seized or destroyed by the intolerant", or to paraphrase that: we can only survive by being intolerant about intolerance.
As we all know, white supremacy and all it's ugly variants are making headlines and empowering those who secretly embrace those views to speak out. There's also the current political mess in Australia over gay marriage, where conservative christians are doing all they can to stop it.
So where do we draw the line on free speech and religious freedom?
We have to draw it somewhere, or our society will become victim to it and we will loose those very freedoms!
The balance is in how we confront them. If we use "violence" (physical, vocal or in any form) we are playing the same game, and when confronted in this way, the intolerant simply dig their heels in and use the opposition to fuel more intolerance.
Respect for their humanity is key. To recognise that we could be the same if we'd been raised in a different environment is a sobering thought. It's a learned trait, something we aren't just born with. So compassion and empathy is the key to any communication, bypassing the rhetoric and reactionary thought processes and focussing on understanding why people are like this.
At the risk of being overly simplistic, it comes down to a lack of love. They never experienced the type of unconditional love themselves that breeds self worth and empathy for others. They are broken and angry, but instead of looking within, they are lashing out at the rest of us.
But they still have to be stopped from spreading this disease, and that's where we have to draw lines. Although love is the only "cure" for these people, we still have to deal with the affects they are having on our society.
The alt right issue is pretty obvious, but the christian right style of bigotry, especially towards LGBT people is more complex because of the religious freedom problems. And that opens a very large can of worms because it will eventually confront all religions on issues of bigotry and tolerance.
Perhaps it's time we stop being afraid of challenging people's belief systems?
We can do this with love and patience without compromising our stand. They believe they are doing the right thing, so we have to talk to their hearts, bypass the religious rhetoric and present compassion and empathy for the broken as our motivation.
We also have to remember that for most christians it's a case of "the bible says so", and that's a tough nut to crack. But with the same level of compassion we can help them to understand that their views are in error, as have been so many christian opinions over the centuries, that had to be adjusted and morality, ethics and science outgrew the ignorance of ancient culture.
We must be strong but loving - compassionate but without compromise - draw the lines but help them gently step over them. It's hard work, but if we can step back from our own reactionary thought processes we will be able to exercise the love they need to see in action.
Tuesday, 15 August 2017
"Real" Christians?
I've been getting a bit of backlash lately. Not from the usual quarters, but from concerned friends. They are worried that I'm too angry about Christianity and religion and point out that I'm painting all Christians with the same brush - that I'm offending those who I shouldn't be offending and that really, I should just get on with loving people, not judging, and living my new found life to it's fullest.
I'm told that I'm still angry at what the church did to me, and that isn't what christianity is about, and I should back off and pursue the love that I preach and leave others to live their own journeys.
I totally understand this. I really do!! And to be honest, I often contemplate just walking away from all this stuff (even Silent Gays) and getting on with living a nice life.
These days, I'm not particularly angry over what has happened to myself (apart from the odd trigger of course), but I am angry over the damage I still see every day from Christianity in all it's forms.

One of the many issues that needs clarification is "real Christianity".
My main concern, obviously, is with fundamentalism. But even this is a broad term with many variations and complexities.
Most of us would assume I mean the bible belt red-neck version, that encompasses biblical literalism and strict dogma built around the Old Testament version of god - the type that believes rational thought has no place and the bible takes precedence over science and psychology etc.
But there is also the type of traditionalism that is embraced by the broader church, that still has strict dogmas based on things like the Nicene Creed and other dogmatic statements of faith that very clearly define what you must believe to be "saved".
Then there are the more liberal doctrines that allow for far more gnostic and esoteric interpretations, right through to those who just follow the example of Jesus as practically as they can and don't even concern themselves with all the other stuff.
So the waters become very muddied when we all respond with our various paradigms based on our experiences, our upbringing, culture etc. Everyone thinks they understand "real" Christianity - that their beliefs are right/best/loving/biblical/just/compassionate or whatever.
Because of all this, we are faced with "what is real Christianity?". So when I dissect and expose so many doctrines and expression of belief, am I calling any particular belief system that is loosely based on Jesus into question? Or all of them?
Can you see the problem here? Where do we draw the line between what is "true Christian doctrine" and what isn't? I realise that everyone will immediately try to justify their biblical interpretations and the traditions of the church and 2000 years of church history etc., but the fact remains that the bible, and Christian doctrines are a mess of ambiguity and contradiction. And the crunch really comes down to when is a Christian not a Christian and, even more important, what are the "fruits" of those beliefs that define your own brand of Christianity.
My "mission" then, is to help bring some clarity to what we believe and why we believe it. The sooner we all realise that every form of religion is totally subjective, with no empirical evidence for any of it, the sooner we can get on with really making this world a better place - of discovering what real love is and actually living it.
You can believe in anything you want, but do so in the knowledge that you are simply adopting something that just feels good to you and empowers you (hopefully) to bring love, compassion and peace to this world.
I'm told that I'm still angry at what the church did to me, and that isn't what christianity is about, and I should back off and pursue the love that I preach and leave others to live their own journeys.
I totally understand this. I really do!! And to be honest, I often contemplate just walking away from all this stuff (even Silent Gays) and getting on with living a nice life.
These days, I'm not particularly angry over what has happened to myself (apart from the odd trigger of course), but I am angry over the damage I still see every day from Christianity in all it's forms.

One of the many issues that needs clarification is "real Christianity".
My main concern, obviously, is with fundamentalism. But even this is a broad term with many variations and complexities.
Most of us would assume I mean the bible belt red-neck version, that encompasses biblical literalism and strict dogma built around the Old Testament version of god - the type that believes rational thought has no place and the bible takes precedence over science and psychology etc.
But there is also the type of traditionalism that is embraced by the broader church, that still has strict dogmas based on things like the Nicene Creed and other dogmatic statements of faith that very clearly define what you must believe to be "saved".
Then there are the more liberal doctrines that allow for far more gnostic and esoteric interpretations, right through to those who just follow the example of Jesus as practically as they can and don't even concern themselves with all the other stuff.
So the waters become very muddied when we all respond with our various paradigms based on our experiences, our upbringing, culture etc. Everyone thinks they understand "real" Christianity - that their beliefs are right/best/loving/biblical/just/compassionate or whatever.
Because of all this, we are faced with "what is real Christianity?". So when I dissect and expose so many doctrines and expression of belief, am I calling any particular belief system that is loosely based on Jesus into question? Or all of them?
Can you see the problem here? Where do we draw the line between what is "true Christian doctrine" and what isn't? I realise that everyone will immediately try to justify their biblical interpretations and the traditions of the church and 2000 years of church history etc., but the fact remains that the bible, and Christian doctrines are a mess of ambiguity and contradiction. And the crunch really comes down to when is a Christian not a Christian and, even more important, what are the "fruits" of those beliefs that define your own brand of Christianity.
My "mission" then, is to help bring some clarity to what we believe and why we believe it. The sooner we all realise that every form of religion is totally subjective, with no empirical evidence for any of it, the sooner we can get on with really making this world a better place - of discovering what real love is and actually living it.
You can believe in anything you want, but do so in the knowledge that you are simply adopting something that just feels good to you and empowers you (hopefully) to bring love, compassion and peace to this world.
Wednesday, 14 June 2017
God (or doctrine) "allows" evil
I saw this article and simply had to respond, mainly because it's indicative of a deeper issue than the one being addressed. Just have a quick read before continuing...
Why do we wrestle with this problem so much? The article puts forward a pretty good theological explanation that may or may not be strictly "biblical", but it puts a nice soft band-aid on it so we don't notice the problem so much.
When we are confronted with the never ending contradictions in the bible and god's character we have to sort it out somehow. This is the purpose of creating theologies and doctrines. Without them we are left to make whatever we can of the collection of disparate writings of the bible (the canon of documents created by the Roman church around 350 years after the fact).
Doctrines are nothing more than man made ideas about how to make it all work.
So this article looks at one of the most asked questions mankind has ever put forward, and because a christian is asking the question they have to look at scripture for an answer. This is where the doctrine machine kicks in. The author has worked hard to reconcile things and takes into account a lot of newer doctrines that have been created recently as people start thinking a little more rationally and logically, daring to question taboo issues.
But as I said, this particular article isn't the main point.
We just keep making up more doctrines to keep this faith alive. We have to! As we realise that something we thought was reasonable a while back is actually nonsensical and possibly downright evil, we have to look at the bible again and create different ways of reading and interpreting it so that we can breath a sigh of relief and carry on again - with a new revelation. And that new revelation builds a whole new set of "movements", all just as judgemental as the last, all claiming to have THE truth (or the latest version specially revealed to them).
The simple reality...
We don't need the bible, or Jesus (sure, there's good stuff there if you can extract it from the crap). We don't need to be "saved". We don't need the latest revelation.
We are enough - as we are. Everything we need is already in us. WE are the source of love. Our inherent sense of empathy, compassion and morality is greater than the god we have created. Time to ditch the book, the doctrines and challenge the paradigms of religious thought.
Live loved 💖
![]() |
| Read this first before continuing |
When we are confronted with the never ending contradictions in the bible and god's character we have to sort it out somehow. This is the purpose of creating theologies and doctrines. Without them we are left to make whatever we can of the collection of disparate writings of the bible (the canon of documents created by the Roman church around 350 years after the fact).
Doctrines are nothing more than man made ideas about how to make it all work.
So this article looks at one of the most asked questions mankind has ever put forward, and because a christian is asking the question they have to look at scripture for an answer. This is where the doctrine machine kicks in. The author has worked hard to reconcile things and takes into account a lot of newer doctrines that have been created recently as people start thinking a little more rationally and logically, daring to question taboo issues.
But as I said, this particular article isn't the main point.
We just keep making up more doctrines to keep this faith alive. We have to! As we realise that something we thought was reasonable a while back is actually nonsensical and possibly downright evil, we have to look at the bible again and create different ways of reading and interpreting it so that we can breath a sigh of relief and carry on again - with a new revelation. And that new revelation builds a whole new set of "movements", all just as judgemental as the last, all claiming to have THE truth (or the latest version specially revealed to them).
The simple reality...
We don't need the bible, or Jesus (sure, there's good stuff there if you can extract it from the crap). We don't need to be "saved". We don't need the latest revelation.
We are enough - as we are. Everything we need is already in us. WE are the source of love. Our inherent sense of empathy, compassion and morality is greater than the god we have created. Time to ditch the book, the doctrines and challenge the paradigms of religious thought.
Live loved 💖
Wednesday, 7 June 2017
Good, Evil, Sin, Love
This is perhaps one of the most important issues we have to face. It's insidious and rules over every part of our lives. In fact it's the basis of the "human condition" irrespective of religion.
I became a passionate Christian at 15.
I was gay, struggling to understand what was wrong with me.
I grabbed the bible and read it nonstop, cover to cover. I absorbed it, and the prayer books, and started listening to the sermons. I loved talking about it and how amazing God was, and assumed everyone else in my church youth group had the same understanding as me!
I was gay, struggling to understand what was wrong with me.
I grabbed the bible and read it nonstop, cover to cover. I absorbed it, and the prayer books, and started listening to the sermons. I loved talking about it and how amazing God was, and assumed everyone else in my church youth group had the same understanding as me!
Inevitably
I discovered that it was wrong to be a christian and be homosexual. The bible
said so and that was that. So I prayed and prayed for it to “go away”. I
started to look for more radical “cures” and went to a “deliverance” ministry
to get the demons cast out. I persisted for a few weeks and went along with the
whole thing, but nothing actually changed, strangely enough!
I
then had some prayer counselling which supposedly got to the deeper spiritual
and psychological causes, but just made me feel like a failure. So I ended up
marrying this really lovely girl, who was a great friend, thinking that would
fix everything, and we’d have a family and live happily ever after. Not a
happening thing.
I
then drifted into Pentecostalism to find a deeper more powerful spirituality
that would enable me to overcome my evil desires. I became a worship leader,
home group leader and dived into the whole lifestyle boots and all, even street
witnessing in Kings Cross.
I decided to get married again! Really stupid, I know, but I was
convinced it would work this time and my dream of a happy family would come
true.
She’d had lesbian relationships so we knew basically what we were up against, but of course we had no idea of just how hard it would be. We had lots of counselling, all sorts of whacky Christian ministries, and finally got involved with Living Waters reparative therapy group in Australia and then over here in New Zealand. We were involved with them off and on for about 15 years, as worship leaders, participants and leaders.
She’d had lesbian relationships so we knew basically what we were up against, but of course we had no idea of just how hard it would be. We had lots of counselling, all sorts of whacky Christian ministries, and finally got involved with Living Waters reparative therapy group in Australia and then over here in New Zealand. We were involved with them off and on for about 15 years, as worship leaders, participants and leaders.
Never
once did we admit that it wasn't working. Sure there was some good insights
gleaned from the teachings and they were beautiful, sincere and loving people,
but I never became one tiny bit straight.
Eventually
my wife became sick with cancer in 2009. I nursed her for nearly 2 years before
she died after which I had something of a meltdown. Our son had to watch his
mum die as we kept hanging out for miraculous healing. We read all the books, heard
countless preachers on every aspect of healing imaginable. Went to conferences
with the best international healing ministries and lost count of the number of
people who prayed and prophesied over her. It was horrific on so many levels,
and it wasn't until after she died I could even attempt to process any of it.
I
had to come to terms with the fact that I’d lived my entire adult life with
depression and suicidality, struggling with the cognitive dissonance of being
gay in a belief system that said I couldn't be gay.
My
core spirituality was based on my experience as a 15 year old, and I’d spent
the rest of my life thinking that fundamentalist Pentecostalism (in one form or
another) was the only genuine expression of that experience.
So
I then spent 12 months unravelling my faith, and coming to terms with my
sexuality. I began to take small steps to embrace my real identity and slowly
become very active in the LGBT community as a spiritual voice for those
silently suffering in churches and religion.
So
now how does that all relate to my topic on the knowledge of good, evil, sin and love”? I'm glad you asked.
Part
of the unravelling process required me to take a radical look at the bible. I
started to look at the original languages, the cultures, social norms,
historical context etc, as best I could without my Christian paradigm. I saw of
course, that all the scriptures about sexuality were completely misinterpreted
(that’s a huge discussion in itself!). If only I’d known that from day one…
But
it didn’t stop there and wasn’t long before I began to see all the flaws in my
belief system. It became clear (to me at least) that humans have an insatiable
assumption that we need holy texts – irrefutable words of wisdom that define
our meaning in relation to God and the universe. Writings that set out moral and
ethical codes, rules and rituals, that are necessary for humanity to survive. But
the biggest problem is that we also assume humans are essentially flawed and
need saving from our inherent brokenness.
This
is quite understandable as we all wrestle with the horrors we inflict on each
other on a daily basis – even down to our own petty squabbles. It seems as if
we really are inherently evil.
(This
is a huge subject of course and countless books have been written about it
already)
Most
religions (especially christianity) are complex systems built on those
assumptions. However, what if we are actually perfect, exactly as we should be,
but all that is missing is our realisation of it? This is a concept that has
always been around in some form but rarely embraced because of the apparent
contradictions in what we experience. After all, despite our best efforts we
all take offence and argue and fight, blaming each other for all our problems.
It’s not a good look, so we have invented religious systems that build on this
paradigm to create a way of hope for a better life.
Now, every single person knows what love is. It’s inherent in our nature as humans.
We may not understand it fully or even experienced it in any meaningful way,
but the deep longing for unconditional love is absolutely universal. In fact,
it’s the only aspect of spirituality that truly is universal.
Deep
down, we all know that the only thing that brings real change towards life and wholeness,
is love.
So
here’s my point (finally!)
The bible myth about the "tree of the knowledge
of good and evil" that Adam and Eve ate from, expresses the basis of the
problem - we keep choosing to look at everything in terms of right and wrong
instead of love.
The
story says that the only thing that would cause them to die was embracing the
desire to know good from evil! Even Paul in the New Testament, hinted at it
often with statements like "everything is permissible but not everything
is beneficial". We keep thinking that the most important thing we can do
is determine right from wrong – sin from righteousness. We think that justice
is only defined in terms of good and bad, so we spend most of our time making
judgements. We are obsessed with having the knowledge of good and evil. Our
entire civilisation is built on this! We want clear cut lines that say “this is
right but that is wrong”. Our legal system is nothing more than countless lines
drawn to define if something is good or bad.
But
if we look to the story of Jesus, we see something very subtle and easily
overlooked in his words to the disciples after the “last supper” dialogue. He
simply said, in possibly his most powerful words, “I'm giving you a NEW command
– love each other the same way I love you”.
Up
to that point he’d supported the principles of the law and 10 commandments, and
had reduced them down to two – love God and love each other. But what he did
here is ditch the “thou shalt” mentality entirely and institute something new.
Love
each other just like I love you. He turned it completely around. The onus was
no longer on us to “love God” first and foremost. He took that out of the whole
equation. The disciples had seen the depth of his love for humanity, and that’s
exactly what he put to them. Love humanity, just like I do.
Stunningly
simple, and bypasses all concepts of laws and rules. Up to that point he’d been
pointing out that living by the law was completely unattainable, and he constantly
upped the ante with things like “you know you shouldn't have it off with
another woman, but I'm telling you - if you even look sideways at a woman you
may as well have had sex with her”. He did this heaps and upset a lot of
people! But then he turned it all around with that one final “new” command. It
was a command for unconditional love.
So,
lets look at this a little closer. The people we all most admire and respect as
examples of life and faith, are those who live from that place of unconditional
love. They don't judge, they simply love. Like Mother Teresa, the Dali Lama –
those types we admire for their sacrificial and genuine love. They don’t preach
doctrines and rules, morals and ethics – they just love unconditionally and
completely.
Here’s
the crunch though. We don't need any holy writings for this. Its already who we
are. As little children we don’t judge, we simply “are” and enjoy life based on
the level of love we receive. Sure, there are heaps of ancient and modern
writings that are incredibly profound and have so much to offer. But I'm
talking about revering these writings, and their authors, to the point of “god’s
infallible words”, “anointed”, “holy” etc. It’s called bibliolatry (the worship
of the writings themselves instead if the deeper message), and most religions
are guilty of it.
When
Jesus said to be like children, he wasn't talking about obeying your parents or
being submissive - he was talking about a simplicity of life and faith – a
returning to that wonderful reliance on love and love alone and the joy and
peace it brings to ourselves and everyone around us.
Christianity
in particular calls us to "repent" - a word that is loaded with
guilt, shame, penance and punishment. But the original word in context with the
Greek language and culture literally means to just change your mind. That's
it!! Just change our minds about who we are. Look at a baby! It has no concept
of right or wrong, good or evil. It’s just a little love receptor, a love
sponge, which gives as much as it receives. So we “repent” of our craving for
the “knowledge of good and evil” and return to that state of innocence. A love
sponge!
This
has to be practical as well, and sure enough, we will still act in unloving
ways as we gradually learn our true identity, but all we have to do is be
responsible for any mess we make. That's all there is to it! That may be
difficult and may require extreme measures to amend for those actions. But the
point is, there is no sense of punishment for wrong doing, or reward for doing
good. It’s a simple matter of being responsible for all we are and do from a
place of love.
Its
living loved. Everything else is a distraction and a returning to that tree.
We
think we need endless books and sacred writings of wisdom that talk of how and
what to do to be good people - but we already are good people - we have just
been convinced that we aren't by choosing to judge what’s right and wrong instead
of living loved.
We
will keep hurting each other, misunderstanding and fighting, but as we begin to
see what love looks like and embrace it for ourselves, we’ll change. The whole
point of love is in embracing imperfection!
How
does this look in daily life? Every decision we make should begin with the
premise that “I am loved – I am inhabited by love – I am love incarnate”. Will
this decision, this action, thought or word come from love and bring love? What
will be its fruit? It may be a very hard decision, but if it’s done with
integrity and honesty, then we can ask no more. Because love covers “sin”, and
we all know that sin is simply “missing the mark”. Yes, it’s another one of
those loaded words that religion has escalated to the ultimate judgement. But
again, the original languages and context reveal it to be a simple “missing the
mark” like an arrow missing the target.
So
after all this – what is love? Most of the western world knows 1 Cor 13 and it
could be said to be the universal standard that depicts pure unconditional
love.
“This love of which I speak is slow
to lose patience—it looks for a way of being constructive. It is not
possessive: it is neither anxious to impress nor does it cherish inflated ideas
of its own importance. Love has good manners and does not pursue selfish
advantage. It is not touchy. It does not keep account of evil or gloat over the
wickedness of other people. On the contrary, it is glad with all good men when
truth prevails. Love knows no limit to its endurance, no end to its trust, no
fading of its hope; it can outlast anything. It is, in fact, the one thing that
still stands when all else has fallen.”
Of
all holy writings, this is probably the one that hits the depth of every soul.
Even if we have never experienced this kind of love, we all crave it. The lack
of it is the cause of all our woes, from war to mental illness.
To
“live loved” requires us to abandon the desire for the knowledge of good and
evil, and extend the same level of compassion and empathy we desire for
ourselves. Then we will begin to see God in us and everyone one else.
Its
a massive paradigm shift, but millions over the centuries (throughout all
history I guess) have discovered that this really is the narrow road – it’s the
real “gospel” (good news), and the only thing that brings real freedom and the
"fruit of the spirit". It’s taking responsibility for who we really
are.
THIS is what changed my life - from internal and external judgement to unconditional love.
Live
loved!!
Thursday, 25 May 2017
The Fatal Flaw
There are many reason I grew out of Christianity. Perhaps the most significant one is this.
Christianity claims to have the one truth that is for all humanity for all time. This is based on it's scriptures, core doctrines and theology. It's essential to understanding the work of Christ and to reject it directly challenges the premise that Christ died for all humanity's sins and that the Judeo/Christian god is indeed the one true god of all the universe.
I believed this most of my life and any inklings of doubt were quickly quelled by reminding myself that "who am I to question god's plans", and "his ways are higher than ours" etc.
But ultimately the problem is insurmountable. If this gospel is for every person who ever existed and ever will exist, and is the most important information in the entire universe that determines not only our well-being in the present but also our eternal destiny, then god has failed to achieve this on a scale that is tragic beyond belief.
We are told that it's our responsibility to spread the gospel to all the world.
Really?
Can we take seriously the idea that god would put this life and death matter into the hands of the humans he apparently created in the complete foreknowledge that they would fail to do so - and fail on a grand scale!
Did he forget about the billions of people before Jesus? Or did he treat them all with the same disdain he had for those he drowned in the flood?
Did he realise that billions of people in all the countries and nations outside of the middle east throughout all history would never hear this message, let alone understand it's implications?
Did he realise that still, countless billions, through no fault of their own have no idea of this one true god and the way to be saved from our sin and his wrath? Or that billions never will?
"But God's ways are higher than ours!!" Yeah right. I'm not seeing it, despite years of genuine attempts to figure out how this works.
This is the fatal flaw in the whole system. God has failed to deliver the goods. Most of humanity is lost, and possibly in ways that are too horrific to contemplate.
I have not had one single descent response to this - ever. Not even the best theologians I've read have addressed this issue in a rational way. They all end up with "his ways are higher..." etc.
The reality is this - whether we like it or not. Christianity is one particular religion that arose from one particular tribe in one particular region. It had no concept of the world as we now know it. It created a god that fitted their small, primitive world view. It worked for them in that context (although I would even question that). It never was and never will be the one truth that sets all humanity free. But to let go of this delusion is to let go of the basic tenets of the belief system, and that will cause a complete crisis of faith - something that most are terrified to allow.
Christianity claims to have the one truth that is for all humanity for all time. This is based on it's scriptures, core doctrines and theology. It's essential to understanding the work of Christ and to reject it directly challenges the premise that Christ died for all humanity's sins and that the Judeo/Christian god is indeed the one true god of all the universe.
I believed this most of my life and any inklings of doubt were quickly quelled by reminding myself that "who am I to question god's plans", and "his ways are higher than ours" etc.
But ultimately the problem is insurmountable. If this gospel is for every person who ever existed and ever will exist, and is the most important information in the entire universe that determines not only our well-being in the present but also our eternal destiny, then god has failed to achieve this on a scale that is tragic beyond belief.
We are told that it's our responsibility to spread the gospel to all the world.
Really?
Can we take seriously the idea that god would put this life and death matter into the hands of the humans he apparently created in the complete foreknowledge that they would fail to do so - and fail on a grand scale!
Did he forget about the billions of people before Jesus? Or did he treat them all with the same disdain he had for those he drowned in the flood?
Did he realise that billions of people in all the countries and nations outside of the middle east throughout all history would never hear this message, let alone understand it's implications?
Did he realise that still, countless billions, through no fault of their own have no idea of this one true god and the way to be saved from our sin and his wrath? Or that billions never will?
"But God's ways are higher than ours!!" Yeah right. I'm not seeing it, despite years of genuine attempts to figure out how this works.
This is the fatal flaw in the whole system. God has failed to deliver the goods. Most of humanity is lost, and possibly in ways that are too horrific to contemplate.
I have not had one single descent response to this - ever. Not even the best theologians I've read have addressed this issue in a rational way. They all end up with "his ways are higher..." etc.
The reality is this - whether we like it or not. Christianity is one particular religion that arose from one particular tribe in one particular region. It had no concept of the world as we now know it. It created a god that fitted their small, primitive world view. It worked for them in that context (although I would even question that). It never was and never will be the one truth that sets all humanity free. But to let go of this delusion is to let go of the basic tenets of the belief system, and that will cause a complete crisis of faith - something that most are terrified to allow.
Monday, 15 May 2017
My Legacy
Many people think that I'm "out and proud", and that my days of living in hidden trauma, depression and self loathing are long gone.
It's been a slow journey out of that mess, and the legacy of that life is deep and lingering. I'm on antidepressants and still have bouts of depression and anxiety. I have ADD that became far worse after the meltdown. I can't absorb complex technical information any more (I used to be a technical writer and Instructional Designer). My brain runs full tilt all the time, dancing from one thing to another without a word of warning. I get confused easily. I'm impulsive. I lose track of what I'm doing. It's not just old age, lol, although I'm sure that doesn't help!
I guess I do give that impression because I'm a passionate advocate for helping people untangle the mess of religion that causes untold damage to millions (and not just LGBT people). I speak about how amazing life is now that I'm free from the bondage and abuse from that belief system.
But there's a legacy (a very large legacy) that I live with - that most who have been through this sort of stuff live with.
Let me explain...
On one level I've never felt more at peace to be free from religion and dogma. I understand love in ways I never thought possible. Life is infinitely better!
But I lived a nightmare for most of my 60 years. I lived a life of shame and guilt - of being a failure, a "freak", faulty, rejected and deeply tormented for being something I couldn't change, which culminated in a meltdown after my wife died.
It's been a slow journey out of that mess, and the legacy of that life is deep and lingering. I'm on antidepressants and still have bouts of depression and anxiety. I have ADD that became far worse after the meltdown. I can't absorb complex technical information any more (I used to be a technical writer and Instructional Designer). My brain runs full tilt all the time, dancing from one thing to another without a word of warning. I get confused easily. I'm impulsive. I lose track of what I'm doing. It's not just old age, lol, although I'm sure that doesn't help!
I struggle every day. It took me 2 years to write It's Life Jim... not only because of the time it took to untangle so much of the mess, but also because my mind doesn't operate in linear coherent ways any more (not that it was ever that good at it anyway). Some days I get up with the best of intentions and clarity only to find it turns to vapour the moment I start to be "productive". I practice mindfulness and go for long walks. I take time as best I can, to slow down. I like my wine and beer, and the odd bit of wacky weed to help slow down the endless barrage of chatter in my head.
I struggle with how most of my life was a complete waste, never finding peace or integrity, self worth and living a complete lie, damaging those closest to me, as well as myself. Sure, there's all the platitudes about my life's journey and nothing is a waste etc... I get that, really I do. But that doesn't help the deep scars left by the endless years of crap.
Daily, "normal" life is not something I do well. I'm one of the walking wounded, with a pronounced limp that I'm slowly realising may never go away. And yet, the paradox is I'm happier than I've ever been. A deep happiness and peace - so much better than my previous life.
One thing I can give, without hesitation, is my integrity and honesty about who I am, what I've done and where I'm at. I can only "share my journey" (cliche alert) with as much honesty as I'm capable of mustering, because that is the only thing any of us can do in the end. Sure I "preach" about the things that have set me free, and I'm passionate about everyone growing into real life and love without fear or dogma. But I'm just me, still discovering my own biases, how my paradigm works, how I affect others, how much I really live what I preach.
My favourite tag line is "Live loved". I'm still learning how powerful and profound those simple words are. Some days are better than others, but it's always a step forward.
The legacy of christianity, for me, is deep. I've seen the utter failing of it's core doctrines. I'm not as bitter as I used to be, and have always recognised that many beautiful, loving people have found a belief system that works for them. They are the ones who have shaped their beliefs around their own inherent beauty, rather than the reality of the belief system itself, but that's a whole other story, lol.
So I guess I'm saying that if I (or anyone) give the impression that I'm suddenly free and perfect after a lifetime of abuse, then sorry, it doesn't work like that.
Now, where's that beer?...
Thursday, 4 May 2017
Pedophile priest forgiven by church...
(Update: this is probably a fake news story, but it doesn't change the issues I'm addressing)
This is not uncommon, as we are all too aware!
Any sane Christian will immediately say that this is not God's will, that it's evil and so on - and rightly so.
I'm not commenting about the subject matter itself though. I'm addressing the whole problem with God allowing this horrific stuff to blacken his name.
Countless atrocities over the centuries, big and small, have been committed by the church. They paint the church as a dark place indeed, despite the glimmers of loving genuine people of the faith.
But here's the problem...
We worry about the tainted image of God and proclaim "but we aren't all like that", and of course that's true. But millions of people don't know that! They have never seen the "good" side. They are ignorant of all you who understand that love is the main thing, so they quite genuinely assume that Christianity is a heap of crap.
God does nothing to stop this.
NOTHING.
He is silent. Yes, you may say, it's up to us to put the record straight and show people how good this god really is, but that never stops this sort of thing. As desperately as we may try to paint a good picture more crap is smeared over the whole thing.
There are lots of trite answers about why god allows this - answers that try to find some sense, but all fail miserably in the light of simple truth and logic. They all end up with the same lame answer - "because god".
People are bitter, angry, horrified, over the hypocrisy of the church. They are the laughing stock. And god is still silent, and not one Christian has a decent response. It's just, you know, because god!
You don't need a religion to be a loving, moral person. We are ALL capable of being better than this god. And better yet, WE then become responsible members of humanity as we work together to confront this type of evil. We don't have to try and justify it all through complex twisted doctrines and theologies. We no longer have a scapegoat.
WE become responsible for love on this planet.
WE are love.
You can believe in a god of some sort if you like, but if you place doctrines and theology above the love of humanity in any way, you have missed the plot.
It's time for humanity to mature, grow up, out of religion and accept our rightful place and responsibilities.
This is not uncommon, as we are all too aware!
| Paedophile priest with HIV who raped 30 children forgiven by church... |
I'm not commenting about the subject matter itself though. I'm addressing the whole problem with God allowing this horrific stuff to blacken his name.
Countless atrocities over the centuries, big and small, have been committed by the church. They paint the church as a dark place indeed, despite the glimmers of loving genuine people of the faith.
But here's the problem...
We worry about the tainted image of God and proclaim "but we aren't all like that", and of course that's true. But millions of people don't know that! They have never seen the "good" side. They are ignorant of all you who understand that love is the main thing, so they quite genuinely assume that Christianity is a heap of crap.
God does nothing to stop this.
NOTHING.
He is silent. Yes, you may say, it's up to us to put the record straight and show people how good this god really is, but that never stops this sort of thing. As desperately as we may try to paint a good picture more crap is smeared over the whole thing.
There are lots of trite answers about why god allows this - answers that try to find some sense, but all fail miserably in the light of simple truth and logic. They all end up with the same lame answer - "because god".
People are bitter, angry, horrified, over the hypocrisy of the church. They are the laughing stock. And god is still silent, and not one Christian has a decent response. It's just, you know, because god!
You don't need a religion to be a loving, moral person. We are ALL capable of being better than this god. And better yet, WE then become responsible members of humanity as we work together to confront this type of evil. We don't have to try and justify it all through complex twisted doctrines and theologies. We no longer have a scapegoat.
WE become responsible for love on this planet.
WE are love.
You can believe in a god of some sort if you like, but if you place doctrines and theology above the love of humanity in any way, you have missed the plot.
It's time for humanity to mature, grow up, out of religion and accept our rightful place and responsibilities.
Sunday, 16 April 2017
Happy Easter!
You didn't really expect a traditional Easter greeting from me did you?
Many of you are used to my "attacks" on Christianity, and I often post stuff explaining my reasons, but my "audience" has slowly shifted, friends have come and gone (although I still manage to keep quite a few traditional christians in my friends list).
So why do I keep digging away at the christian faith?
Why can't I just get on with life and leave people to believe whatever they want?
Glad you asked!!
Basically, everyone is free to believe whatever they want. Why shouldn't we? Our personal beliefs are our business. Of course, the one defining condition is how do those beliefs affect others, and how do they really affect us?
There are countless types of religious and spiritual belief systems, Christianity being one of the major players. But even the major ones have endless official and unofficial variations, often at complete loggerheads with each other - to the point of hatred, war and even genocide.
What does this tell us?
People spend their entire lives justifying their beliefs in an effort to claim they have the truth. There are a lot of psychological reasons why this happens, but whatever the reasons, humans love to be right about whatever they believe. We love to feel special and better than others.
All this clearly tells us that there is no "one truth" - no one true religion. No one is "right".
When we have the guts to step back from our beliefs and see how all religions and beliefs are nothing more than subjective opinions we can see them for what they are - the damage they can do - the good they can do - and how irrelevant they are in the end.
I will continue to dismantle traditional Christianity. Not because I have an axe to grind, but because the only way forward for humanity is to grow out of our need for this type of religion, to grow up as it were, into being creatures responsible for each other and our own lives. Religions by their very nature, create division, separate humanity into "us and them".
I'm not attacking people, just challenging what they believe and why, with the hope that we can all move past the need for this type of religion and grow into understanding reality, love and life together.
Happy Easter!!
Many of you are used to my "attacks" on Christianity, and I often post stuff explaining my reasons, but my "audience" has slowly shifted, friends have come and gone (although I still manage to keep quite a few traditional christians in my friends list).
So why do I keep digging away at the christian faith?
Why can't I just get on with life and leave people to believe whatever they want?
Glad you asked!!
Basically, everyone is free to believe whatever they want. Why shouldn't we? Our personal beliefs are our business. Of course, the one defining condition is how do those beliefs affect others, and how do they really affect us?
There are countless types of religious and spiritual belief systems, Christianity being one of the major players. But even the major ones have endless official and unofficial variations, often at complete loggerheads with each other - to the point of hatred, war and even genocide.
What does this tell us?
People spend their entire lives justifying their beliefs in an effort to claim they have the truth. There are a lot of psychological reasons why this happens, but whatever the reasons, humans love to be right about whatever they believe. We love to feel special and better than others.
All this clearly tells us that there is no "one truth" - no one true religion. No one is "right".
When we have the guts to step back from our beliefs and see how all religions and beliefs are nothing more than subjective opinions we can see them for what they are - the damage they can do - the good they can do - and how irrelevant they are in the end.
I will continue to dismantle traditional Christianity. Not because I have an axe to grind, but because the only way forward for humanity is to grow out of our need for this type of religion, to grow up as it were, into being creatures responsible for each other and our own lives. Religions by their very nature, create division, separate humanity into "us and them".
I'm not attacking people, just challenging what they believe and why, with the hope that we can all move past the need for this type of religion and grow into understanding reality, love and life together.
Happy Easter!!
Thursday, 6 April 2017
The Psychological Legacy
If you've read my book "It's Life Jim..." you'll be familiar with how my mental state was affected by my life of battling sexuality with religion and the constant fight with depression and suicide ideation.
When my wife died it all came to a head and I had a "meltdown" or whatever you want to call it. The symptoms were a relentless combination of heavy depression (like walking around covered in a wet dark blanket, unable to think beyond the pain and confusion that keeps pounding your head), Intense anxiety attacks (that created a physical gnawing in the gut, confusion, a strange disassociation from my environment and a feeling that I was about to burst into tears), and an escalation of ADHD symptoms (lack of focus, restlessness, confusion, thought's racing etc). The suicide ideation thankfully went!
This lead to counselling and medication and living on the benefit. There was no way I could hold down a job!
Nearly six years later I'm doing pretty good, but there's the legacy that I just have to live with despite my best efforts. All of these symptoms are still around. Yes, I get days where the depression hits (although nothing like it was) and I still get anxiety attacks, and the ADHD symptoms are the bane of my life.
I've learnt the triggers (mostly) and how to handle it all. I can sense better when I might take a nosedive, and I know how to "roll" with it and not be fearful.
But it's still there. This is the legacy of a life ruled by religious control, cognitive dissonance, self loathing and emotional abuse. Will it ever go away? I'd like to think so, but I'm not holding my breath.
It's like this for countless others. We are presumed to be over it and "all better now". Sure, we've moved on and even enjoy life in ways we never dreamed of. My life is fantastic and fulfilling. But the legacy quietly lives on, reminding us daily.
Be gentle with yourself.
Learn your weaknesses and accept them.
Roll with them, don't fight them.
Find the best way through it - socialise or retreat - talk to people or hide in your cave... there's no right or wrong, just whatever enables you to move through it safely.
Get help if needed, any time, don't be a martyr.
Life is good, no matter what the past has done to us. Life is rich and full of wonder and love.
Live it!!
When my wife died it all came to a head and I had a "meltdown" or whatever you want to call it. The symptoms were a relentless combination of heavy depression (like walking around covered in a wet dark blanket, unable to think beyond the pain and confusion that keeps pounding your head), Intense anxiety attacks (that created a physical gnawing in the gut, confusion, a strange disassociation from my environment and a feeling that I was about to burst into tears), and an escalation of ADHD symptoms (lack of focus, restlessness, confusion, thought's racing etc). The suicide ideation thankfully went!
This lead to counselling and medication and living on the benefit. There was no way I could hold down a job!
Nearly six years later I'm doing pretty good, but there's the legacy that I just have to live with despite my best efforts. All of these symptoms are still around. Yes, I get days where the depression hits (although nothing like it was) and I still get anxiety attacks, and the ADHD symptoms are the bane of my life.
I've learnt the triggers (mostly) and how to handle it all. I can sense better when I might take a nosedive, and I know how to "roll" with it and not be fearful.
But it's still there. This is the legacy of a life ruled by religious control, cognitive dissonance, self loathing and emotional abuse. Will it ever go away? I'd like to think so, but I'm not holding my breath.
It's like this for countless others. We are presumed to be over it and "all better now". Sure, we've moved on and even enjoy life in ways we never dreamed of. My life is fantastic and fulfilling. But the legacy quietly lives on, reminding us daily.
Be gentle with yourself.
Learn your weaknesses and accept them.
Roll with them, don't fight them.
Find the best way through it - socialise or retreat - talk to people or hide in your cave... there's no right or wrong, just whatever enables you to move through it safely.
Get help if needed, any time, don't be a martyr.
Life is good, no matter what the past has done to us. Life is rich and full of wonder and love.
Live it!!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






